Our Buffalo Cheeseburger

  • Depending on topping choices, you may want to start them now
    • Caramelized onion – these will take some time, so get your pans pre-warmed for later and give yourself plenty of time, more the better
    • For toasted buns, set the oven on broil 550 degrees and butter both top and bottom buns
    • Cut/slice cheese 
    • Wash and dry (bibb) lettuce, place on plates
    • Fried egg – this takes no time at all, so you can start cooking the egg towards the end
  • Grab your biggest, heaviest frying pan/dutch oven (we choose cast iron dutch ovens) and get the heat cranking.  Your choice must include a lid! You want these to be piping hot and ready to go.
  • Place one shot glass of water beside each dutch oven for later
  • Using 1 lb thawed bison meat, open with scissors
  • Use only hands from here on out
  • Separate ground bison into two halves, gently round meat into soft ball
  • Shape using flat palms, rotating w fingers (push down w open palm and rotate)
  • Be gentle.  Don’t squeeze, don’t press. Lock in that moisture!
  • Place thumb in middle of patty and create an indent on top and bottom of the patty, this will help the burger keep shape as it cooks
  • Place patties on a plate
  • Heavily salt outside of patties and add pepper 
  • Add additional spices as you see fit
  • Flip patties and season as you just did
  • One dutch oven per patty are at max blast.
  • Get highest temp oil available, such as avocado or grapeseed and add oil to pan, don’t do anything until oil is near/starts to smoke
  • This is a good opportunity to throw in garlic, onion, etc should you choose, but keep it simple, it will get charred
  • Cook patties (min/side): 4 mid-rare, 5 mid-well
  • Don’t mess with it, except for the flip
  • The flip: lift lid, flip patty and place in a different area of the dutch oven 
  • Place cheese on patties – build a little log cabin
  • Add any other toppings, this is your last chance, as the cheese melts!
  • Pour in shot of water and place lid
  • On the side, prep buns
  • Toast to preference 
  • Place bibb lettuce curling up to collect dripping juices on the toasted bottom bun
  • Start the egg immediately after the burgers are flipped.
  • Assemble burger.
  • Enjoy!

Related posts

Leave a Comment